Showing posts with label Louis XIV. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Louis XIV. Show all posts

Friday, February 24, 2012

In Touch With the Past

Some of you may know that I’m currently taking a course on history methodology, in preparation for writing my senior thesis next year. If you do know, however, you probably didn’t remember until I mentioned it just now: it’s a somewhat boring class, which could and should last one hour every other week, rather than two hours every week. The students and professor alike do their best to keep the conversation dynamic, but if, at the end of each class, you asked me what I’d learned, I’m not certain what I’d answer. Perhaps I’ve just been spoiled with good seminar; after all, discussing historical methodology at a party won’t get you a date, in the way discussing the Enlightenment or European Fascism will. Although I’m looking forward to finally reading Edward Saïd’s Orientalism, and Natalie Davis’s The Return of Martin Guerre, there is one topic definitely missing on my syllabus, covered only vaguely in the first week’s reading, and tangentially in one article in the fifth week.

That topic is what I call concreteness in history. It has to do with a very delicate balance in historical writing. When historians seek to describe the events of the past, they information they present falls somewhere on a scale of specificity, ranging from the anecdote on the one side to the generalization on the other. Although I emphasize that this is a scale, and that there is a well-sized grey area, most event can be classified without much difficulty as one or the other. Whereas an anecdote (from Greek, “unedited”) is a specific event involving or in the presence of a certain individual or group at a particular time and place, a generalization (from Latin generalis, in contrast to specialis) sweeps anecdotes into a blender, sets it to “purée” for ten minutes, and tells you how the smoothie tastes, thus “editing” the unedited. If a generalization is quantitative, we call it a statistic. When selecting, interpreting, and presenting the primary sources that reveal the events of the past, historians must write in both anecdotes and generalizations. This is a fine balance to strike: how often to generalize, and how often to recount anecdotes.

Too many anecdotes, and too few generalities, leaves the reader uncertain just to what he should importance, and how much. Herodotus is a classic example of this (Ibn Daud is too, but less well-known, and a certain neighbor of mine might not appreciate criticism of Sefer HaQabalah). The man just loved anecdotes. For instance, he tells us, the names of the bravest soldiers in every battle, and of individual acts of heroism. For instance, at the battle of Plataea, the Athenian Sophanes “wore an iron anchor, fastened to the belt which secured his breastplate by a brazen chain; and this, when he came near the enemy, he threw out; to the intent that, when they made their charge, it might be impossible for him to be driven from his post: as soon, however, as the enemy fled, his wont was to take up his anchor and join the pursuit” (Histories 9.74, where there follows a second, contradictory story about Sophanes). Even Herodotus’s generalities are more curiosities to be admired than meaningful topical summations. For instance, he describes non-Greeks to his all-Greek audience in part by their foreign eating-habits: Assyrians lived exclusively on fishcakes; Massagetaeans were cannibals, milk-drinkers, and lacked agriculture; and Persians were unmatched in the decadence of their cuisine (Histories 1.200, 1.216, and 9.82, if you don’t believe me). Although the citations reveal that I’m pulling these from different books, my point is that these may be generalizations, but by the time you pull up Facebook again, you’ll have forgotten these passages. This is the problem of Herodotus: though his descriptions of battles are riveting, and his anthropological observations are fascinating, one week from now, you won’t remember who Sophanes is, nor will you know anything about Assyrian eating habits.

The opposite problem is much more common among contemporary historians, particularly (in my own experience), those who study East and Southeast Asia. For instance, all I remember about the Tang Dynasty (618-907) from a semester-long class on premodern China and Japan is that some people played polo in the North. So that I won’t be comparing apples and oranges, I’ll choose a written source, instead. Seymour Drescher wrote the most boring assigned course reading I have ever read, the introduction to a book-long debate over the precise connection between capitalism and the abolition movement (the same people involved, the best example being the Quakers). Throughout the entire Introduction, only the name of a single historical actor (a wealthy British merchant) is ever mentioned, and the non-scholarly reader is left clueless as to just what the natures of the abolitionists and capitalists were like. All I can remember is the premise of the article: I derived no benefit, because there were only generalizations, no anecdotes.

John Lewis Gaddis, in his Landscape of History (don’t bother reading it), writes that historical writings are to the events of the past as maps are to a landscape. Historical writing cannot describe all aspects of the past without becoming as vast, clumsy, and “unedited” as the past itself (or, rather, the vestiges it leaves behind, which Gaddis calls “relics of the past,” which, upon historical scrutiny, become primary sources). To borrow a statisticians’ adage about models, all historical writings are false, but some are very useful. Anecdotes must be selected, and generalizations must be made; major questions remain which ones, how many, and in what proportion to each other (bearing in mind, of course that no single historian, no matter how dedicated, can ever exhaust all primary sources on a subject). Many students of the past have successfully struck this balance over the years. To name just a few, Edward H. Schafer (The Vermillion Bird), Thomas Cahill (How the Irish Saved Civilization), Arturo Valenzuela (The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes: Chile), Benedict Anderson (“Census, Map, Museum” in Imagined Communities), Mark Kurlansky (Cod), Philip Deloria (Indians in Unexpected Places), Joseph Ellis (Founding Brothers), Belinda Davis (Home Fires Burning), Ada Ferrer (Insurgent Cuba), John Ellis (Eye-Deep in Hell), David Fromkin (A Peace to End All Peace), and every contributor to The Cultures of the Jews have all produced excellent, informative, well-written, and well-balanced works.

My favorite example, however, of balanced historical writing, is Thucyidies.. In Book I of his sadly-unfinished History of the Peloponnesian War, the old Greek general establishes the great conflict, that all Greece ought to have seen coming. Athens and Sparta had been on a collision course since the Persian Wars more than a half-century before: the Delian League had become the Athenian Empire, and every year, more poleis were joining, ever increasing the Athens’s resources of ships, warriors, and treasure; before long, Sparta, long the most fearsome Greek polis, would be in an obvious position of inferiority: Athenian power posed a direct threat to Spartan hegemony, and Athenian coercion of traditional Spartan allies, most importantly Corinth, and most cruelly, Megaros. But though Thucydides’s political acumen was great enough to write such cogent generalizations of international relations in Classical Greece, he was also capable of including the anecdotes necessary to make the generalities stick. One of Thucydides’s famous contrasts between Sparta and Athens, for instance, is that the former’s power is land-based, and the latter, naval. This is best illustrated in his numerous descriptions of battles. For instance, early in the war, an Athenian fleet fights a group of enemy ships, who are so frightened by the Athenians’ navy, famed as the mightiest across the Hellenic world, that they form an outward-facing circle, and back water to maintain a safe distance. The Athenians threateningly close in circularly, and, eventually, their enemies bump into each others, their sterns and riggings tangle, and they surrender to the Athenians. The ease with which I just wrote this passage (notice the lack of citation) should convey Thucydides’s ability to make his ideas memorable. What he has done is make history concrete: the reader understands larger themes (generalizations), through specific incidents (anecdotes).

To return to Gaddis’s metaphor of historical-writing-as-map, if generalizations are the paper of the map, then anecdotes are the pushpins which “fix” it, and prevent it from curling up around the edges as the map ages. With no generalizations, pushpins in the wall are boring things; with no anecdotes, maps, no matter how valuable, will remain forever furled in the corner.

Concreteness is the effect of a proper balance between anecdote and generalization: it is not the balance itself. When the two are in proper proportion, one knows the physical, visibly human actions on a small scale, as well as the significance of these actions to a larger historical narrative. What many modern historians fail to do, in their generalization-based history, is remind the reader what his generalizations mean, and what they look like. When I was in France, studying at the Sorbonne, I vigorously studied the Finance Ministry of Louis XIV. I read and reported on the entire process of direct (and indirect) tax collection and assessment. The different courts and tribunals, the various officers and commissars, the lands of election and of estate, their calendars and timetables: all I tried to explain to my classmates, with my friend Pauline Renoir, in 20 very, very short minutes. Throughout the project, though, I was bothered by two closely-related questions as to the historical relevance and importance of the presentation I was crafting and the material I was sifting through. The first was: was any individual involved in this hierarchy of transfer actually aware of any of the other actors? My conclusion, at the end, was a tentative no: the higher-ups didn’t care how each receveur particulier (the crucial intermediary link in the chain) came up with the money he delivered to the receveur general, and the humble collecteur had no way of knowing what happened to the tax money he levied. My second question still remains unanswered: how did the average taxpayer physically pay his taxes? Would twelve soldiers, armed to the teeth, knock on his door demanding money, the way so many bad Robin Hood films have taught us to imagine tax collection? Or was he obliged to visit the collecteur and his staff with a purse of silver coins at some sort of regional office?

The negative answer and non-answer to my questions reveal that the books I was reading lacked concreteness: I could not ascertain the physical, visible aspects of the actions described therein. Concreteness is important for two reasons. First, it forces you to understand what you are saying when you are making historical claims. If, for instance, I made the sweeping claim that “in its early years, Pinochet’s dictatorship in Chile was particularly brutal,” something I learned from my course on Latin America, and somebody pressed me for examples, I would know how to respond. I could say: “The day after Pinochets’s September 11th 1973 coup, approximately seven thousand known supporters of the just-murdered democratically-elected president Allende, were rounded up, and detained in the stadium in the capital city of Santiago. Many of these people were beaten, tortured, and executed by machine gun fire.” Here, I not simply using a blanket statement, such as “coup,” “repression,” or “military crackdown.” If pressed for details, I could provide the example of Víctor Jara, the famous leftist folk singer, most of whose upper body was broken in the severe beating he received, who was taunted by his tormenters to try to play his guitar in such a state, and who began the composition of a poem (successfully smuggled out), unfinished because he was dragged away to be executed by machine gun.

Such an event is as vivid as it is shocking; and this brings me to my second point: concreteness is necessary in order to “fix” certain events and milieus in the mind of the reader. Just as medical students have their mnemonics (“On Old Olympus’s Topmost Top, A Fat-Eared German Viewed A Hawk” in order to memorize the names of cranial nerves), history students need their mental pictures, sound bytes, and video clips to prevent what they are learning from dribbling out of their ears. For instance, I still bear in my head the vivid picture of a housewife in wartime Berlin smacking an offending policeman with her milk pot. This instantly summons forth a host of other images and ideas: starvation and shortage, the colored rationing cards, steaks cut out of every horse which collapsed in the streets, the terrifying gun-toting and sword-wielding German police, the vast slaughter of one third of Germany’s pig population, the “turnip winter,” public kitchens, black market butter, k-bread and double-k bread: I suddenly recall the milieu of starvation in Berlin in World War I. Like turning over a seemingly ordinary stone, only to reveal a scuttling swarming universe beneath, each one of these scenes (and I have collected many, over the years), “reveals” a throng of interrelated images.

Many historians write concretely, consistently: others do not. Some professors at Cornell include concreteness in their lectures: many others do not. In less than one year, I will, for the first time ever, be in the position to write as a historian does: I only hope that my writing will be as concrete as it is insightful, and as original as it is interesting.

~JD

“A salient feature of the plantation period is the number of European accounts that actually credit slaves with the introduction of specific foods to the Americas, all previously grown in Africa” (Judith Carney, In the Shadow of Slavery: Africa’s botanical legacy in the Atlantic World, 123).

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Visiting the Dutch

It was a perfect day to spend indoors, at the Louvre, looking at Dutch paintings: cold, dreary, wet, and miserable. At least there aren't any dikes to overflow, here in Paris. On my way, I finally stopped by the large domed building which I pass every day on my way to the Sorbonne, having finally decided that I ought to figure out exactly what it was. It turns out that it is the Val-de-Grace church, equipped with a benedictine monastery. The founder of Val-de-Grace is none other than Anne of Austria, wife of Louis XIII, who founded the monastery in thanks for the birth of a son (guess who that was). When Louis XIV was seven years old, he laid the first foundation stone of the edifice: the AA motif on the walls still recalls the original patroness. Mass was in session at the time, but the church is open to visitors most days of the week, and moreover, has become the museum of military health.

In any case, I had agreed to meet up with Nick later that afternoon, to visit the galleries of the Louvre together, but I had about three hours to spend alone with the Dutch paintings. I had told myself ahead of time that I was only going to look at paintings I enjoyed, but I nevertheless stopped to look at the 15th- and 16th-century religious paintings and portraits of dead important people. One of them, van Eyck's "The Virgin of Chancellor Rolin," from 1444, was apparently quite famous. It depicts Philippe le Bon (comte de Bourgogne) kneeling and praying before the Madonna: it's the background, depicting a sort of heavenly cityscape of Jerusalem, that makes the piece so famous, I think. However, for a while, there really isn't anything in these earlier Dutch paintings that interests me. But it's around 1580 that you begin to see some of the detail, such as the grime under Saint-Jerome's fingernails, that makes the Dutch paintings so interesting to look at. Beggars appear in certain compositions, and war makes its appearance as destructive brutality, alongside more glorious images. This is the age of the early Brueghels, a multi-generational clan of painters. I saw Jan "Velvet" Brueghel's masterpiece, depicting one of the battles of Alexander the Great; however, I far preferred a four-part series depicting the essences of the four classical elements. I particularly liked looking at "Fire," a scene of dwarven blacksmiths hard at work underground; in the foreground are piles of the masterpieces which they have crafted: suits of armor, metal urns, tools, jewelry, etc. This is one of the wonderful aspects of Dutch paintings: the piles of stuff which often clutter their foregrounds! I often wonder how they painted many of these, such as "Fish Merchants at their Stall." Did they paint from real models, or from books, or out of their heads? I wonder exactly how anatomically correct all of these fishy wares are...

In any case, I quickly got into the Rubens, the Van Dyck, and their contemporaries. There was even a double portrait of the two Dutch masters, isn't that neat? Perhaps my favorite part of this section was the Hall of the Medicis. Marie de' Medici, the wife of Henri IV, commissioned a 24-piece series of paintings chronicling her life's story, which now take up the entire hallway. To us, the idea seems ridiculously egotistic, and even laughable; at the time, though, it must have been a grand series of paintings. The story begins before her birth, showing the Fates spinning out her destiny, and different episodes include her marriage, coronation, reception of the regency when Henri IV leaves for war in Germany, her acceptance of the regency upon his untimely death, her diplomatic missions, etc. The episodes are highly romanticized -- one canvas doesn't even contain any human beings, only the classical Greco-Roman gods deciding the destiny of France and Spain. At the end of the epic, I was more impressed with Rubens than with Marie de' Medici!

Eventually, I arrived at the section on Rembrandt and his circle -- only to find that I really don't like the Rembrandt selection at the Louvre. Now that I've seen the original "The Night Watch" in Amsterdam, perhaps my standards are too high, but there was really only one painting that really impressed me, a 1660 self-portrait titled "Portrait of the artist with an easel." It has that truly Rembrandt je-ne-sais-quoi to it; half of the painting is obscured in shadow, and it is the way that the visible part emerges that makes it so wonderful to admire. Around this time, I looked at my watch, and realized that I only had a little while left in the galleries before I met Nick. I sped up, and made it at last to the final Dutch room, where I found the work of my other favorite Dutch painter, Vermeer. The Louvre owns two Vermeer paintings; one of them, the iconic "Lacemaker," is currently on loan in Philadelphia. The other, "The Astronomer, or rather the Astrologer," painted in 1668, is less well-known, but no less beautiful. It has light shining in through the window; what could be better? The folds of the tablecloth, the details of the globe, the sketches on the book before the scholar: all are detailed and accurate. Scholars now think that it is likely that Vermeer used a device known as a camera obscura, lent to him (?) by his friend Van Leeuwenhoek (yes, the same guy we learned about in Bio glass when learning the history of the microscope), which allowed him to trace his subjects. Perhaps this is true, I don't know; however, if Vermeer owed the quality of his work exclusively to a camera obscura, why can't anyone else paint like him? Camera obscura or not, Vermeer will never cease to interest me (fun fact: according to Wikipedia, the subject of "The Astronomer" could be Van Leeuwenhoek, who might even have commissioned the painting).

I headed outside into the light drizzle, and Nick found me while I was in the middle of taking the picture of a newly-engaged couple, who had asked me to take a photograph of them in front of the glass pyramid (very common). He and I bopped around the the 17th- and 18th- century French sculptures, before heading over to the Mesopotamian and Iranian antiquities. We found the famous Code of Hammurabi, one of the western world's most ancient of legal documents, and also a stele of "Baal of the Lightning," one of the Mesopotamian gods who features prominently in the Tanakh. Sitting down for a moment, I happened to look at some Iranian pottery, dating from around 1200 B.C.E. -- only to notice the very same aspects found in "Orientalizing" Greek pottery! The connection is now so obvious; the stylized flower blossoms interspersed with rows of stylized animals in profiles is clearly the same! I always knew that "Orientalizing" indicated eastern influence, but I had never before seen any examples of that eastern influence; now I have.

We meandered through the French painting section. We saw the famous "Turkish Bath" painting my Indres, which represents quite well the Ottoman harem in the European mind (note: when we think "harem," the image we conjure up of naked empty-headed hedonistic beauties surrounded by fierce eunuchs is that of the late Ottoman harem; a "harem," in, say, Middle Kingdom Egypt, was a completely different institution). The painter was 82 when he finished this work, which seems a little old, to me, to still be obsessed with naked women. That's the job of people my age, isn't it? We moved on, and Nick pointed out the only Impressionist paintings in the entire Louvre; there are only about eight of them, with a Monet and a Renoir, as well as a few Pissaro. The collections of the Louvre are just too old, for the most part, to have any significant possessions later than the mid-19th century. We also saw an extremely eye-catching 1780 painting of "The Eruption of Vesuvius" by an Austrian artist, and we kept on running into more portraits and busts of Diderot. Near the end of the visit, we came across a computer monitor that showed us how art historians analyzed paintings, using a portrait of Madame de Pompadour as a model. We both realized that, as much as we enjoy looking at certain paintings, we're never going to be able to read a painting like that. Good grief, those art historians even read the titles of the books on the shelves, and pick out complimentary shades of blue in completely different parts of the painting!

So, I'm all done with my work. Time to hit up the museums while I still can! Mom and Dad arrived yesterday, and we met for dinner; today, we visited the Musee Carnavalet together; and tomorrow, when they return from Versailles, we're eating dinner again together.

~JD


"L’Etat fixe les prix et les cours de la monnaie, achète la production, contrôle la circulation des biens et des hommes" [The state fixed the prices and the weights of the coinage, purchased finished goods, and regulated the circulation of goods and of men] (Jacques Mathieu, La Nouvelle-France, p. 150).

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Ecouen & Chantilly

Feeling relieved: I finished writing my 8-page paper on the Young Turk Revolution early this afternoon, and on Friday, I took a 2-hour test, an in-class essay, in which we were expected to analyze "La Cour du Lion," a poem by La Fontaine which criticized the court of Louis XIV. That being done, I could enjoy a double-chateau weekend with my fellow EDUCO students.
I got up, if not early, than earlier than I would have liked, in order to trudge my way off to the Place Saint-Sulpice where we met our bus. I sat with Joe on the way out to Ecouen, which is under an hour's ride north of Paris.

Ecouen now houses the nation's museum of the Renaissance. Built in the first half of the 16th century, during the Francois I / Henri II phase of French architecture, the chateau was owned by Anne de Montmercy, constable of France, the second-richest man in France, after the king. Yes, "Anne" is a woman's name in French, too, but he was named after his aunt, Anne de Bretagne, the wife of Louis XII, whom you may remember from my post on Langeais, where Anne and Louis hooked up on Christmas half a millennium ago. In any case, this Montmercy character owned 120 castles across France, and this was just one of them, decorated in fantastic Renaissance style, and even more embellished with some of France's finest Renaissance art objects and artifacts. We had two guides, who led us through both castles; our guide was mediocre, but the other one, apparently, was nothing short of horrendous.

I was quite impressed with Anne's home-decorating style. There were ornamented cornices, frescoes depicting scenes from the Old Testament on every chimney, Corinthian columns, open scallop-shells around every corner, and carved fleurs-de-lys, crescents, rainbows, and other insignia throughout. Anne's personal symbol is an A and an M joined together by a sword, and his animal of choice is an eagle lacking feet and a beak (don't ask me why). Flanking one courtyard enterance were copies of two of Michelangelo's famous pieces, now known as the Rebel Slave and the Dying Slave, of which the originals are now a the Louvre. In fact, this is where the originals stood, from the time of Anne (who acquired them from Michelangelo, who had originally sculpted them for a papal tomb) until the time of the French Revolution. Even the floors were once richly, richly painted, with military and vegetable motifs, the yellows, blues, and greens standing out most prominently in the reconstruction in the center of one room.

But Ecouen is also a museum, and it contains, if you ask me, a greater wealth of art than the Cluny does (or maybe I just prefer the Renaissance to the Middle Ages? Beats me). Perhaps what most dazzled me was the collection of gilded-silver drinking vessels, purely for display purposes, which were never used. The masterpiece of the chateau was among these, a 16th-century German-manufactured cup in the shape of Daphne being transformed into a tree -- personally, I found it rather ugly and ostentatious. Really, however, the chateau housed art in every media known to Renaissance Europe. There was a large display of 16th-century Majolica-style plates, richly-painted ceramics in a style developed in Spain, and brought back from Italy by French artists. A few of these were even modest enough that I wouldn't mind having them in my house. One of the most famous pieces in Ecouen is the series of ten 16th-century Flemish tapestries depicting the story of David and Bethsabée. I tried very hard to get a good picture of this, but the lights were too dim (for the preservation of the tapestries, no doubt), so, unlike the other pieces I'm describing, you won't find pictures on FB. Something I found rather curious about the composition, however, was the far-left side of the first tapestry in the series, which was a separate "panel" if you will (what is a tapestry but a Renaissance comic book with insulation functions?), showing a man sitting and reading from a book -- reading the story of D & B, in other words, which the artist went on to vividly illustrate. Why choose to begin a composition this way? In any case, the tapestries were finely-made.

All of the chateau's masterpieces, it seems, were made in Germany. In addition to the cup, there was an impossible-to-photograph goldsmith's bench, owned by Auguste I, Elector of Saxony, which had very, very fine carvings down the length. Even more magnificent and ostentatious was the so-called "Ship of Charles Quint," made in Augsbourg around 1580, a clock in the shape of a great galley. Little figures of human beings were stationed around the deck of the clock-ship, including an enthroned Charles Quint in the center, many of whom nod their heads or otherwise move about when the clock is in motion, which it wasn't at the time we visited.

However, I found that by far the most interesting collection was the one which I found by myself, after or guided tour was over (done at what felt to me like a running-pace), in our thirty minutes of free time. Hidden away at the end of a wing is the Iznik collection of Ottoman ceramics, many of them created under the reign of Suleiman the Magnificent. Beautiful floral swirls on white backgrounds characterize the 16th-century manufactures of the town of Iznik, for which the collection is named. The collection used to belong to the Cluny Museum, but was sold, and thereby dispersed, near the end of the 19th century. Only the diligence of the museum's curators managed to reunite the fabulous collection, over the course of the second half of the 20th century, of around 450 pieces now on display.

We packed back onto the bus: our next stop was Chantilly, known for its cream, its lace, its horses, and, yes, its castle, which was also owned by Anne de Montmercy and his descendants, including the Conde family and the Ducs d'Aumale. Chantilly is really a gem, from the outside, nearly as beautiful, in my opinion, as Chenonceau. The current edifice is mostly a 19th-century reconstruction of a 16th-century chateau nearly entirely destroyed in the French Revolution. The building is now the Condé Museuem (Musée de Condé), which, according to our guide, is the second most-visited art museum in France, after the Louvre (I have difficulty believing that it is more visited than the d'Orsay). First, of course, we had to have lunch at the chateau's kitchens. I'm not going to whine about it for too long, but I had some difficulty securing a vegetarian option; however, the conversation was good (and mostly in French), there was bottomless wine served, and the food itself wasn't bad.

After ungluing ourselves from our seats with difficulty, we took a tour of the castle-turned-museum, and then the gardens. When you enter, one of the first things that you see is an allegoric fountain statue of Louis XIV laying low (terrassant) the Fronde, the great rebellion (really a series of rebellions) the kingdom faced 1648-1653, during Louis's minority. It was the Grand Condé, once proprietor of this chateau, who led the most significant resistance to royal authority (he was unhappy that he and his military buddies hadn't received enough promotions and honors during the Thirty Years' War); there was a significant political reason, in other words, for this fountain's strategic placement!

The Chantilly Chapel, which I believe is part of the original castle (I could be wrong) is pretty amazing. It has a high-vaulted ceiling, with Anne de Montmercy's distinctive AM-Sword emblem. He also depicted himself and the rest of his family in stained glass. At the far end of the chapel is an unpretentious black urn, which contains the hearts of all of the Princes de Condé -- I don't know if it also contains alcohol, or what, but they're still there.

There is a nice collection of 17th-, 18th-, and 19th-century paintings in the Condé Museum. Many of them have Oriental themes, partially because the Duc d'Aumale went on campaign in Egypt with General Bonaparte, and, like the future Emperor, came back with an orientalist fascination. There are some famous portraits of the Cardinals de Richelieu and de Mazarin, a painting of Madame holding a portrait of Monsieur, many horse-themed tableaux (Chantilly is the French capital of horses), a great painting of an aging Moliere, and various depictions of the Grand Condé. There is a room of paintings depicting Louis XIV's campaigns, one of which I recognized from the cover of my copy of Voltaire's Siecle de Louis XIV. There are also a few pieces of historical interest relating to the Grand Condé, including the chest he used when he was on campaign, the pink diamond he kept about his person, and the cabinet used to hold his mineral collection. The grounds of Chantilly were by no means the gardens of Versailles, but they were certainly very pleasant to stroll through, in the early evening. They were liberally strewn with larger-than-life marble statues of personae from the Grand Siecle, including Moliere, and, of course, Condé. It's only fair to mention here that our guide was far, far more knowledgeable about Chantilly than he was about Ecouen, and not only had more to say, but could also answer questions in a straightforward manner.

I also made it to the Louvre this weekend, just for about an hour, but it might have been the best hour I have spent there yet. I visited the Italian statuary collection, and saw the originals of the Rebel Slave and the Dying Slave, whose copies ornamented the courtyard of Ecouen. Really, the whole room, and the adjoining rooms, are full of good things -- the statures that once flanked the entrance to the Borgia's palace, a marble bust of a young woman with an elaborate lace collar (yes, Mom!), Cupid reanimating Psyche with a kiss, an enormous statue of Jupiter, etc. Many of these, amidst the other statues, were really 2nd-century Greek and Roman statues restored in the 16th and 17th centuries (taken from the collections of Mazarin, Richelieu, and others). It was extremely interesting to see how the people of the Renaissance and the Grand Siecle re-imagined the missing pieces of these statues. For instance, there is a truly incredible black marble statue from antiquity, representing an elderly fisherman; but its 17th-century owners thought that the subject was Seneca the Younger in his death throes (Seneca was commanded by Nero, I think, to commit suicide)! Likewise, the waist downward of a statue of a seated pharaoh with his hands on his knees was dredged up, dating from the 2nd millennium B.C.E., I think. The upper half was completed, and looks somewhat like other seated statues -- except it infinitely less detached from reality, and has so much more the semblance of a human being in time and space.

~JD

Sa Majesté Lionne un jour voulut connaître [One day his majesty the Lion wanted to know]
De quelles nations le Ciel l'avait fait maître. [Of which nations Heaven had made him the master]
Il manda donc par députés [He summoned his delegates]
Ses vassaux de toute nature, [His vassals of every kind]
Envoyant de tous les côtés [Sending from all sides]
Une circulaire écriture, [A circulatory letter]
Avec son sceau. L'écrit portait [With his seal. The writ explained]
Qu'un mois durant le Roi tiendrait [That for one month the King would hold]
Cour plénière, dont l'ouverture [An outside Court, of which the opening]
Devait être un fort grand festin, [Would be a very great feast]
Suivi des tours de Fagotin. [Followed by the tricks of Fagotin].
Par ce trait de magnificence [By this stroke of magnificence]
Le Prince à ses sujets étalait sa puissance. [The Prince spread forth his power to his subjects]
En son Louvre il les invita. [He invited them into his Louvre]
Quel Louvre ! Un vrai charnier, dont l'odeur se porta [What a Louvre! A real charnel house, whose odor wafted]
D'abord au nez des gens. L'Ours boucha sa narine : [Immediately to the noses of the people. The Bear plugged up his nostril]
Il se fût bien passé de faire cette mine, [He had just made this face] (?)
Sa grimace déplut. Le Monarque irrité [His grimace displeased. The irritated Monarch]
L'envoya chez Pluton faire le dégoûté. [Sent him to Pluto, to turn up his nose]
Le Singe approuva fort cette sévérité, [The monkey strongly approved of this severity]
Et flatteur excessif il loua la colère [And, excessive flatterer, he praised the rage]
Et la griffe du Prince, et l'antre, et cette odeur : [And the claw of the Prince, and the den, and this smell]
Il n'était ambre, il n'était fleur, [There no amber, there was no flower]
Qui ne fût ail au prix. Sa sotte flatterie [That wasn't garlic to it (?). His foolish flattery]
Eut un mauvais succès, et fut encore punie. [Had poor success, and he, too, was punished]
Ce Monseigneur du Lion-là [This milord the Lion]
Fut parent de Caligula. [Was kinsman of Caligula]
Le Renard étant proche : Or çà, lui dit le Sire, [The fox was close; and then, the King said to him]
Que sens-tu ? Dis-le-moi : parle sans déguiser. [What do you smell? Tell it to me, speak without concealment]
L'autre aussitôt de s'excuser, [The other immediately excused himself]
Alléguant un grand rhume : il ne pouvait que dire [Alleging a terrible cold: He could only say]
Sans odorat ; bref, il s'en tire. [Without sense of smell. In short, he withdrew]
Ceci vous sert d'enseignement : [This serves as a lesson]
Ne soyez à la cour, si vous voulez y plaire, [Be, at the court, if you wish to please there]
Ni fade adulateur, ni parleur trop sincère, [Neither a drab adulator, nor too sincere a speaker]
Et tâchez quelquefois de répondre en Normand" [And try sometimes to respond in Norman].

(Jean de la Fontaine, Fables, livre VII, fable 6).

Friday, November 4, 2011

Big Day

Wow, I had a great day, no joke. Here's a breakdown.

6:30: I woke up early because my neighbor was listening to TV in her room, even though we made a noise-control pact earlier in the year that she wouldn't make any noise after 4:00. I felt kind of gross, not having slept well, partially due to the anxiety of the expose that was due the next day; that is, Friday. I lay in bed, even after my alarm went off, just not wanting to face the day.

7:15: I struggled out of bed, put on my nicest button-down white shirt and the pair of shorts without the hole in it, and ate some yogurt while reviewing my expose transcript.

8:00: Class began in the Provinces of France building in the Cite Universitaire, where I live. The first order of the day was my joint expose with Pauline. The assignment was the analysis of one of one of the ministries under Louis XIV; on my suggestion, we had chosen the ministry of finances, not only because it was the most famous and apparently the most important, but because a certain Mother of mine talks a lot about the Comptroller General, a certain M. Colbert (and, hey, I am taking this class partially because I just want a better understanding of what the family historian studies). Louis made a real revolution of the whole royal administration when his personal rule began in 1661, and he began with the finances. Pauline explained the general power structure of the ministry, why it was part of Louis' government-by-council, and how it managed to control just about anything else. I discussed first the presence of the ministry in the provinces (mostly a description of royal taxation, the ministry's most important task), and then the judicial limits and institutional rivals of the ministry. The prof. grilled us, asking me, for instance, what the royal domain was (successfully fielded), what the most important indirect taxes were (I got gabelle right, but not traite), and whether I was certain that the Court of Justice I was describing wasn't actually a Chamber of Justice (it was a Chamber).

10:00 After class, my prof. talks to me about the weekly assignments that the class is supposed to be completing, and which I have been doing my best to complete, but which I have not been fully understanding, apparently. Pretty, much every student needs to prepare a weekly "introduction" to the week's primary-source reading. Basically, we don't need to actually write a composition on the reading, but we need to prepare an introduction as if we were. The prof. (he's a prof. in France, but he would just be a student in the U.S.) really doesn't want me to work too hard on these intros, because of the language barrier. He also discussed the expose, saying that our main problem was that we chose the most complicated ministry; we should have just written about War or the King's Household, or something like that. Oops. Furthermore, although the whole project was well-done and well-researched, part II, the part on which I had lavished the most amount of time, was off-topic, because it was not about the ministry itself, only about the process which it supervised. At least Pauline was patient with me, as she always is. I don't feel comfortable being the object of indulgence and lax guidelines, but it's true that all of the other students have been writing introductions and preparing exposes for three years now, and know what the instructors expect of them. I don't. I think the instructors are happy with my effort, even if the results are sub-par; that could just be me, however. I walked back to my dorm with Pauline and her friend, who left to get on the Metro; Pauline had woken up at 5:50 that morning in order to be certain of arriving on time...

10:50 I left on my run, which I really needed, after that expose. No, really. I took a 50-60 minute lope around the Cite U grounds, and then around the Montsouris Park. I was kind of tired, so I didn't push myself too hard (I left that for the next day). I get back to my dorm, find that the bathrooms are finally open again, take a quick shower, make a sandwich, which I eat on my way out.

12:25 I boarded the Metro at Porte d'Orleans. Although I don't usually ride the Metro, my rendez-vous is at 1:00 in the 2nd arrondissement, and I just wouldn't have had the time to walk that distance. I arrive at the Bourse metro station (bourse has many meaning in French, including "chest" and "scholarship," but in this context, it means "stock market"), and wait outside of the exit, where I'm supposed to meet Prof. Longino (EDUCO pres.), a tourguide, and the other students, none of whom I see. Where is everyone? I decide to just walk over to the Musee Carnavelet instead, and not wait around for a tour I can't find.

1:10 I see Prof. Longino, who is walking towards me; apparently, the Metro has 2 exits, and, no, the info I received did not specify outside of which one. Well, no use complaining: the tour begins of the financial district of the 2nd arrondissement. There's a Parisian saying which I should mention before I go any further: La Rive Gauche pense , et la Rive Droite dèpense, or "The left bank thinks, and the right bank spends." The left bank (south of the Seine, the side of town where I spend virtually all of my time) is the location of the Latin Quarter, whereas the right bank, which I rarely visit, now, is the site of the banks, the stock exchange, etc., as well as many of the large department stores, such as the Galleries Lafayette. Our guide showed us a few of the local sites, such as a street designed by Napoleon I, designed entirely with pillars and other Egyptian-style motifs, and brought us around to one of the former giant warehouse/department stores of the 19th century, as well as to the former Parisian branch of the bank of Lyons, which was remarkable for 1) its very small minimum deposits, and 2) its universal accessibility: you could draw upon the same account whether you were in Paris, Lyons, or any of the other branches. A little but of the general history which our guide described to us was familiar to me already (such as the 1720 failure of John Law's "System"), or I had learned from the documentary which Prof. Longino had forwarded to us ahead of time, "Au Bonheur des Dames," which the history of the Grands Magasins ("department stores") of Paris, in particular, that of the Bon Marche, but she was also full of observations on city planning, art nouveau architecture, the Paris skyline, and quotations from Balzac and Zola.

3:00 We ended the tour on the top floor of the Galleries Lafayette. The view is phenomenal from there, and it's even better when you're with a guide who can tell you which steeple is which. It's also only from there that you can really appreciate the size of the Paris Opera House, which is just next door, and even higher! If you ever happen to be in Paris, and walk by the Galleries Lafayette, I highly recommend you take the 10-20 minutes to mount the stairs (checking out the colorful art nouveau cupola on the way) and take in the view. The girls all went back inside to go shopping, and I realized that I had the rest of the afternoon to do whatever I wanted. What did I want? I wanted to check out the Louvre (for the 4th time).

3:40 I entered the Louvre, and headed to the temporary exhibit, on the world of Alexander the Great. I saw some great stuff, and some not-so-great stuff. In general, what makes the Louvre better than most other museums is that it's collections are so enormous that it can afford to show the absolute cream of the cream, the masterpieces of the masters, etc. However, in the Macedonia exhibit, everything was out for exhibit, even objects of secondary importance to the life, times, and legacy of Alex. But let me focus on the positive. I saw an amazing golden Bacchic funerary crown of oak leaves, for Alex's dead son, Heracles; I saw silver vessels from the tomb of Phillip II, Alex's dad (and, in my opinion, more deserving of credit than his universally-known son). I saw examples of Macedonian glass-work (mostly long perfume bottles), gold-work (many spiral motifs and forms), and pottery (OK, it looked an awful lot like other, contemporaneous Greek pottery). There were grave goods, including two or three "reconstructed" tomb dioramas, coins, highway markers, pillars, statues, and figurines. I saw a slightly worn bust of a passionate young Alex, made shortly after his premature death, and a bronze "aegis-bearing" statuette of him, a motif which became a sort of popular talisman.

6:00 I got a call from Bruno, while leaving the Louvre, and we decide the meet the next day, to visit the Parisian catacombs (wait until the next blog entry to read all about it).

6:25 I stopped by Gibert Jeune, in order to pick up a copy of Moliere's L'Ecole des Femmes (The School for Wives). Gibert Jeune is one of the two stores I really enjoy in France, and I wish could be found in the U.S. (the other is my favorite boulangerie). It is a massive bookstore, with a mix of used and new items, taking up several buildings just south of the Place Saint-Michel. I couldn't find any used copies, but the new copies, complete with an introduction and copious notes, was only 2,80, which is pretty cheap for France.

7:10 I make it to the student cafeteria at CROUS, in order to eat dinner.

8:25 I get back to my dorm, and read Le Roi-Machine for most of the rest of the evening.

12:00 I go to bed early -- it's been a really long week!

"Plus il est traite comme un dieu, plus il se comporte en petit bourgeois dans son quotidien... il se plait a entendre pour la emieme fois les airs a sa gloire composes par Lulli, et que les musiciens de l'Academie viennent lui chanter" [The more Louis XIV was treated as a god, the more he acted like a petty-bourgeoisie in his daily life. He was satisfied to hear, for the ninth time, the odes to his glory composed by Lulli, which the musicians of the Royal Academy came to sing for him] (Jean-Marie Apostolides, Le roi-machine, 138).

Saturday, October 22, 2011

Chateau de Versailles (Interior)

Versailles is a baroque monster crouching in a garden.

But let me explain; two weeks ago, I, with three other Americans, took a train out of Paris, for the artificial town of Versailles. Why do I call it artificial? Because the town was plopped down on the countryside when Louis XIV decided that he wanted a new palace, in order to better contain his nobles. Perhaps I exaggerate, but Louis was, in my opinion, both a megalomaniac and an egomaniac, and one of his greatest talents was his creativity in finding ways to remind the rest of the world that he, the Sun King, was at the center of the solar system.
After we passed security, and assured our free admission thanks to our student IDs, the girls and I split up (it was around 11:00 by this point). Ilana and Emily wanted to eat crepes in the gardens, and enter the chateau when the crowds had thinned; I wanted to enter the chateau immediately, so that I could guarantee that I had absorbed the whole interior before I relaxed in the gardens. Alice opted to go with the others, and so we went our separate ways.

And here, unfortunately, is where the detail ends. I became so quickly overwhelmed with the rest of my work that I never took the trouble to "write up" my travel experience while the matters were still fresh in my mind! Although I did take notes (as I usually do), most of the information can be found in the captions of my FB photos. So why repeat everything? Just enjoy the photos as they are; that should be visual tour enough of the triumph Louis XIV.

However, there's one thematic point that I'd like to get across. I left the chateau shortly after 6:00, and arrived back in my dorm at around 9:00 -- in other words, I had spent 12 hours of my day on this visit. I visited every room open to the public in the castle proper, and also hiked, circumventing the garden, to the Trianon and the Petit Trianon, where I likewise visited every room (I never made it to the Jeu de Paume, unfortunately). I never had time to visit the gardens.

And the astonishing thing is, that the girls ended up spending the whole day in the gardens, and didn't stop to enter the chateau proper until after it had closed! This, then, is the point: Versailles is simply so massive, that it cannot be visited in a single day, no matter how determined the tourist (and I assure you that I am very determined).

As for today, it's Toussaint, and the rain ruined my plans to visit the Cluny Museum. Maybe on the weekend...

~JD

"A la mort de Jean II, en 1479, il faut parler d'Espagne: son fils Ferdinand qui a epouse en 1471 Isabelle de Castille lui succede en Aragon; le couple se fait accepter en Castille" [After the death of Juan II, in 1479, one must begin to speak of 'Spain': Juan's son Ferdinand, who in 1471 had married Isabelle of Castille, succeeded him in Aragon; the royal couple made itself recognized in Castille] (Jean-Philippe Genet, Le Monde au Moyen Age, p. 231).

Monday, September 26, 2011

Chateaux II: Return to the Loire!

Back to the Loire Valley, but this time, with EDUCO! The rendez-vous was at 7:45 in the 6th arrondissement, so I got up around 6:00, and trotted off to catch the bus. I slept through most of the bus ride out; at noon, we arrived in the village of Amboise, home of both the royal chateau of the same name, and Clos Luce (Da Vinci's house, if you remember that entry). We had until 1:30 to stroll through the town and eat lunch. I had made a sandwich the night before, which I ate as a checked out the ramparts of Amboise, even managing to take a picture of its funny-shaped exterior, from below. Still during lunch hour, I took a stroll to Clos Luce's Da Vinci Park, taking the opportunity to examine several of the gadgets, and listen to several parts of the Leonardo-guided tour, that I hadn't before. Particularly interesting was an explanation of his study of the "human machinery," and of his recognition of the similarities between a cow's stomach and our own, and a frog's nervous system, and our own; at one time, he had ten cadavers, which he had dissected.

I met back with the rest of the EDUCO students (and had a bit of a discussion with our guide about Gothic Flamboyant architecture), and we all visited Clos Luce as a group. I hadn't noticed it the first time around, but there is a secret underground passageway leading from the chateau of Amboise to Clos Luce (it's closed to visitors), which Francois I used to furtively visit da Vinci. I also hadn't noticed that Marguerite de Navarre had her own bedroom at Clos Luce, for her visits to her brother's hired genius.

Most people don't know about Marguerite de Navarre (aka Marguerite d'Angouleme), and I think that it's only fair that I introduce this exceptional woman. Queen of Navarre, and older sister of Francois I of France, Marguerite was a highly-social, highly-astute woman, best remembered today for her great work of literature, the Heptameron (modeled on Boccaccio's Decameron), a collection of seventy "framed" stories. However, she was a true Renaissance woman, and seemed to be everywhere, meeting everyone there is to meet in the Renaissance (her friendship and fascination with da Vinci is a perfect example of this). Apparently a quick thinker, she wrote while traveling in her carriage. A purveyor of tolerance, she offered shelter to the much-persecuted Protestants. Her statue now stands in the Jardin Luxembourg, and you can see my photo of it on Facebook.

After trotting around the Parc da Vinci, where I played the tour guide for a few of my friends, we hopped back on the bus, and traveled to one of my favorite chateaux -- Chenonceau, the queens' chateau with the two magnificent gardens. Again, I noticed a few things I hadn't before, such as the massive mother-of-pearl cabinet offered as a wedding present to Henri II and Catherine de Medicis by the Republic of Venice, and the Flemish tapestry illustrating this happy event. Our guide seemed to recognize my general interest for all of the history surrounding us, and happily chatted with my friend Ade and me about the furniture, paintings, architecture, and tapestries. As I've mentioned before, there is absolutely nothing like visiting a chateau with a historian, nothing like it at all.

Next stop was wine-tasting at Pere Auguste, a family-owned winery that produces Touraine wine. The business is fairly small, and it was one of the owners who gave us a tour of the presses and fermenting tanks. I nearly had a moment of confusion, due to the identical pronunciation of the words for "rooster" (coq) and "grapeskin" (coque). There were fruitflies in the winery, which was a bit unnerving, but the wine was quite good. There were four qualities -- white, red, rose, and sparkling -- and I'll admit that I preferred the Rose, but wasn't too wild about the red. The wine cost 15 Euros for three bottles, which is a very good deal in France, and the winery made quite a good revenue that day from the American tourists!

Back on the road, we arrived at the countryside hotel where we were to spend the night. We had rented out an entire building, where we were three-to-a-room. There were only five male students who had come on the trip, however, so Nick and I jumped to grab a double together (there are a few more boys who didn't show up, but yes, EDUCO is almost all girls, and every current staff member is female). After about 10-15 minutes just to put our things away, and find out in which room the cute girls were staying, we headed over to the dinner room, where we had a far, far better meal than I think anyone had expected. The sole vegetarian got an omelet and courgettes to go with his fusilli, but it was a good omelet. After dinner, our guide led us in some French drinking songs, "Les Chevaliers de la Table Ronde," and "Buvons un coup, buvons en deux."

Soon after dinner, the party started. I hadn't realized it, but many of my classmates had purchased wine in order to consume it that night, together. I couldn't contribute much, but my friends were more than happy to share. We had a pretty good time, sitting together in the middle of a field, and playing various games designed to divulge our sexual lives. I managed to teach Dead Monkey to the rest, which went over surprisingly well. I had a very good time, and didn't get trashed.

Next morning, up at seven. Not fun, after a night like that! Still, Nick and I stumbled over to the breakfast room, beating the rest of the bleary-eyed crowd. Before long, we hopped back on the bus, headed for Blois.

I'd like to retract every negative statement I made about the royal chateau of Blois in my last entry on the town (published about six weeks ago). Although I maintain that the town feels like a tourist trap, and that the Maison de la Magie just across the way is a cheesy swindle, the only fault I have with Blois is that photography is forbidden, and my only quarrel with our tour of the chateau is that it was too quick. The chateau is absolutely fantastic, architecturally, because there are four distinct historical building periods discernible to the naked eye, even to me. Standing in the central courtyard, one look at the red-brick 15th-century Italian-style Gothic flamboyant wing constructed under Louis XII, turn ninety degrees to see the amazing 16th-century Renaissance wing ordered by Francois I, and turn another ninety degrees to see the unfinished 17th-century Classical wing ordered by Gaston, duc d'Orleans. When Gaston was in the midst of construction, his brother, Louis XIII, had a son; suddenly, Gaston was no longer heir to the throne of France. His allowance being cut off in such an abrupt fashion, he lacked the funds to complete his architectural plans, let alone demolish the older sections of the castle, as he had planned. For this reason, the conglomeration exists as it does today. Blois has been fabulously and meticulously restored with paintings, tapestries, and furniture, almost as well as Langeais. The castle is the site of a famous murder, that of Henri II's brother, who during the wars of religion was supported by the ultra-catholic faction; with the support of the first estate and a large section of the third, he was likely to become king. Henri disposed of him, summoning him to his (Henri's) presence, where he (the duc) would be without his customary bodyguard. Months later, in a fabulous boomerang effect, Henri II was himself assassinated. This event was followed by the War of the Three Henris (I'm not kidding about this), leaving, finally, Henri IV, founder of the Bourbon dynasty, and author of the Edict of Nantes, as king, in the last decade of the 16th century. Naturally, Henri IV was assassinated only a few years afterward... You can also see the secret cabinets, concealed in the wall, where Catherine de Medicis hid important documents of state, etc. (no, not poison).

Next up was another castle I had not visited, the Chateau de Beauregard. To be honest, it's nothing more than a hunting lodge, owned by Henri II's secretary of state. The building itself is not terribly interesting, historically, nor particularly beautiful; the grounds are abundant, but none too interesting. The floor and walls of the upstairs gallery, however, are the real treasure trove of the chateau. The floor is finely decorated with delft porcelain tiles, depicting a 16th-century army on the march, each row of tiles depicting a soldier bearing different arms. The walls, meanwhile, are covered with dozens of portraits, depicting the principal actors in French politics, reign-by-reign, from the time of the Hundred Years' War until the time of Louis XIV, the sun king. Our guide gave us a rapid explanation, explaining who was who. Many of the historical personages were not even French; Francois I was situated beside Suleiman the Magnificent, and Charles V of the Holy Roman Empire.

Following the tour was one of the most sumptuous and gourmet meals I believe I have ever had, and certainly the nicest I have had in the last few year. We sat in the Orangerie, and enjoyed plate after plate of fine French food -- couscous, tomato, quiche, salad, wine, cheese, good bread, decent red wine, strawberries in wine, etc. There was good company too (I sat with some very cool people, including all four of the other male students on the trip), and though several unforeseen events did occur, they served more as conversational topics than as anything capable of ruining a meal. The first was the fat spider I spotted floating in my wine, after I had taken no more than a couple of sips. The second was the fact that, unlike at the hotel where we stayed the night, the Orangerie had not prepared a vegetarian meal in advance for me, so they just threw together an omelet (surprise, surprise), but at least they didn't complain. When David found a lock of hair in his salad, we assumed that it was meant for me, who had had the temerity to mention the spider.

The waitress had kindly brought our whole table a new jug of wine after the arachnid incident, and so I drank a little bit more than I should have; I still felt a buzz when we arrived at Chambord, the great pleasure-house of Francois I. The chateau is so vast that in my two visits, I still haven't seen everything, but I did notice a few points of interested that I had missed on my first round. The first was the office, complete with furniture, where Louis XIV had dictated the repeal of the Edict of Nantes (he signed it at Fountainbleu). I had also missed the beds of Louis and of the king of Poland, and one of the three titanic ceramic stoves installed by the Marechal of Saxe (all three men were proprietors, at one time or another). I also visited the rooms dedicated to the Compte de Chambord, so-called Henri V, reading about the man on whose shoulders so much royalist hope rested, the "miracle child" born after the assassination of his father.

We sadly had very little time to visit the chateaux, but the trip was amazing. I dozed for part of the bus ride back to Paris, and also played Contact with the other students. Now I'm back, class has begun at La Sorbonne, and I'm (finally) making some French friends. Hope all is well with you.

~JD

"Enfin le regime egalitaire -- qui serait l'acte de tolerance --les deux confessions placees sur le meme pied, le culte de l'une et l'autre librement exerce partout cote a cote, la participation a la vie publique assuree a tous -- cette solution n'est pas plus realisable, les esprits et les moeurs s'y opposant; et c'est l'explication majeure des difficultes rencontrees par Henri IV pour retablir la paix a l'interiuer de son royaume"[By the end, the establishment of an egalitarian regime -- in other words, an act of tolerance, the two sects placed on equal footing, both cults freely exercised everywhere, side-by-side, participation in public life guaranteed for all -- this solution was no longer possible, with feelings and mores in such opposition; and this is the major explanation of the difficulties encountered by Henri IV in bringing peace to the interior of his kingdom] (Robert Mandou, Introduction a la France moderne, 173-174).