Showing posts with label John Steinbeck. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Steinbeck. Show all posts

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Tzav Tropical Sermon


 With another year's Tropical Sermon Contest come and gone (mad props to Elliot Dine and Perry Swergeld, by the way, for coming in 3rd and 2nd, respectively), I thought I'd fulfill my promise to publish my sermon, on parshah Tzav, on my blog.  Enjoy, for those of you interested in such things!
            Shabbat Shalom, everyone!  This week we read Parshah Tzav, the second parshah in the book of Vayikra.  In this portion, Moshe initiates Aharon and his sons into the priesthood, and sanctifies an altar for their use.  He clothes Aharon in the garments of the Kohen Gadol and the other kohanim in their own uniforms, anoints them with oil, and places blood on their right thumbs, their right big toes, and the outer cartilage of their right ears.  Most importantly, he carefully instructs them in the process of the korbanot, or offerings, including peace offerings (Zevach Hashlamim), the twice-daily meal-offerings, etc.  This section concludes with the verse
הַשְּׁלָמִים וּלְזֶבַח וְלַמִּלּוּאִים וְלָאָשָׁם וְלַחַטָּאת לַמִּנְחָה לָעֹלָה הַתּוֹרָה זֹאת
This is the law for the burnt offering, for the meal offering, for the sin offering, for the guilt offering, for the investitures, and for the peace offering (7:37).
            There are times at which reading the Torah feels much like reading a textbook.  This week’s portion is such a time.  The word Torah itself means something like “instruction” or “guide,” and I think that it is with this in mind that we should approach Tzav as well as last week’s parshah Vayikra, reading them as a guide to korbanot, written in large part for the practical use of the kohanim.  That being said, even in the absence of the Beit Hamikdash, the portion should remain important to the rest of us, as do all parts of the Torah.  As Rabbi Shimon says in Pirkei Avot (4:13), while the crown of priesthood may belong to the kohanim, the crown of Torah belongs to us all.  The law is all of ours to study and educate ourselves. It is worth mentioning that by spelling ou the process of the korbanot so explicitly in the book of Vayikra, Judaism prevents the monopolization of knowledge by an esoteric priesthood.  As Rabbi Tzvi Freeman has observed, even young children would be able to notice and point out errors in the Kohanim’s procdures.  It is also for this same reason, the education of all in the Jewish law, that the book of Devarim instructs all Jews to write their own Sefer Torahs (Devarim 31:19), a mitzvah now usually observed by giving a copy of the Tanakh or the Chumash to B’nai Mitzvot.  In this way, all Jews may study and learn the law.
            Instruction and education are very important Jewish values.  Knowledge of the law and ethics of the Tanakh and the Talmud is necessary to making the right choices, when leading a moral life as an observant Jew.  This is as true for the process of making sacrifices as it is for the proper recitation of Ashrei as it is for the knowledge of when it is and is not acceptable to lie.  As Hillel states in Pirkei Avot, “a brutish man cannot fear sin [and] an ignorant man cannot be pious” (2:6).  In other words, education and knowledge are necessary for an upright lifestyle.  I think that it is at this point of the year, in the month of Nissan, that teaching, learning, and education should be on all of our minds.  The core of the Seder of Pesach is the mitzvah to teach future generations an important chapter in our national history, specifically, the exodus from Egypt, when God began his relationship with the entirety of the Jewish people, rather than specific individuals, namely the Avot (Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov).  It is written in the book of Shemot, “And you shall tell your son on that day, saying, "Because of this, the Lord did for me when I went out of Egypt" (13:8).  The education of future generations is necessary for maintaining the Jewish tradition and way of life.
            Although I have been speaking specifically of Jews, this is a sermon on American values, and the six and half million American Jews (to whom the 613 commandments apply) make up only about two percent of the country’s population of around 312 or 313 million people.  For this reason I emphasize that just as education is necessary for an observant Jew, it is also necessary for a responsible American citizen.  The Founding Fathers firmly believed that education was necessary for the formation of informed citizens who could vote responsibly in a republican form of government.  For instance, the Northwest Ordinances of 1787 set aside the 16th of the 36 sections of each new township in the Northwest Territories to provide land and funding for a public school.  The bill explicitly stated that “morality, and knowledge being necessary to good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged.”  Of the thirty-nine men who signed the Constitution, sixteen of them sat in the First Congress which unanimously passed this bill; a seventeenth, President George Washington, signed the bill into law.  (Therefore when I say that the founding fathers supported public education, I am neither being vague about which founders I mean, nor about just what I mean by support.)
            The provision of land for public schools, however, is only an auxiliary measure of the Northwest Ordinances, one of the most important bills passed by the first Congress.  The main purpose of the bill was to regulate land distribution in the Ohio Valley and beyond for the ever-moving westward frontier of the young nation (yes, I know that there were American Indians already inhabiting this land, whom the lawmakers did not take into account, but that is the topic for another time).  Those of you familiar with the Northwest Ordinances, the Homestead Act of 1862, and other historic land bills know that land was parceled out in portions large enough for a family, these bills requiring that the owners remain on the land for several years before they could officially take possession of the property from the government.  American values held that every family had the right to its own plot of land, to hold as self-sufficient, independent producers.  This same importance placed upon the rights of all people to a plot of their own land, we also find later in the book of Vayikra, in which it is stated that every plot of land be redistributed every fifty years to its original patrilineage:
אֲחֻזָּתוֹ אֶל אִישׁ תָּשֻׁבוּ הַזֹּאת הַיּוֹבֵל בִּשְׁנַת
During this Yovel year, you shall return, each man to his property (Vayikra 25:13).
            This practice prevented too much land, the most important form of property throughout most of the history of human civilization, from being concentrated in too few hands, a concern from earliest times.  For instance, in the early 6th century B.C.E., the late years of the First Temple period in the kingdoms of Yehudah (while these agricultural laws were still in effect), in the Greek city-state of Athens, maldistribution of wealth created civil strife, as the poor had no choice but to use their own persons as collateral to secure usurious loans from the wealthy landed aristocracy.  The situation remained unstable even after the cancellation of debts by the famous legislator Solon (in the famous σεισάχθεια, or “shaking off of bonds”) and social unrest continued for decades in Attica.  The law of the Yovel promoted social justice in the land of Israel, seeking to ensure that all families would have the economic means of supporting themselves.
            I argue that this insistence on independent means, enshrined in both 18th- and 19th-century America and in the Torah, is the importance which we place on one’s ability to provide for oneself as a social goal.  We find this same ethic in the Talmud: Rabbi Yehuda said, "Anyone who does not teach his son a trade teaches him thievery" (Kiddushin 30b).  In other words, an inability to provide for oneself leads directly to crime and to social disorder.  It is in the interest of both the individual and the rest of society that he or she not find him- or herself with no income, no job, and no assets.
            In our postindustrial society, where virtually all farming is done by large corporations, and the traditional family farm is a rarity, the ability to provide for oneself no longer depends upon land tenure.  Rather, it depends upon labor: today, about 65% of all personal income in the United States is accounted for by employees’ wages.  And labor, that is, the ability to take and keep a job, depends upon education.  According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor statistics, the 2011 unemployment rate for Americans without a high school diploma was 14.1%, the rate for those with only a high school diploma was 9.4%, the rate for those with a bachelors’ degree was 4.9% (all statistics cover only those over the age of 25).  Wages also depend on level of education: the median annual wage of a high school dropout is $23,452, whereas that of a holder of a bachelor’s decree is $54,756, more than twice as much.
            Yet the public education system in the United States is in decline today, millions of Americans lack even high school diplomas, and “young Americans today are less likely than their parents were to finish high school.”  Public education in the United States is also in decline relative to the rest of the world: According to a study at Michigan State University, “A slightly higher proportion of American adults qualify as scientifically literate than European or Japanese adults.”  Our national level of education is also in decline relative to its own past: in the late 18th century, the United States had the highest literacy rate in the world, but a report from the United Nations Development Programme in 2011 ranked it as 10th in the world in literacy.  The absolute figures are sometimes staggering: although there are several different figures as to how many American adults are illiterate, dependent partially upon the precise definition of literacy, the National Right to Read Foundation estimated the figure at 42 million in 2002, while the U.S. Department of Education placed it at 32 million, or about one in seven, in 2009.
            Although adult education is a cure such problems, an improved system of primary and secondary school education is more effective as a preventative measure to illiteracy and ignorance.  Federal and state money cannot solve everything: Brazil lavishes money on its very poor system of public schooling, and yet its literacy rate remains at only 90%.  That being said, I strongly disagree with Governor Rick Perry, who in November made the campaign promise to abolish the Education Department if elected President.  In this year’s State of the Union Address, President Obama recommended that all states pass laws that students not be allowed to leave high school until they either graduate or reach the age of 18; this would be a bold move, but I see its passage, especially in all fifty states, as highly unlikely.  Many point out to the low standards of teaching in the United States, which I have personally experienced.  In my senior year of high school, my Government teacher, despite having been born in New York, having attended Buffalo State University, and teaching at Ithaca High School, was able to name neither the governor at the time (David Paterson), nor his recently-resigned predecessor (Eliot Spitzer).  The woman to whom my training in civics was entrusted was working a second job as a waitress, and could think of no lesson plan more creative than showing video clips from YouTube.  Many suggest that we need is a new generation of passionate, informed teachers.  Some members of the Cornell Jewish community are contributing to this effort: seniors Nate Schorr and Sarah Myers will be Teaching for America this coming year, and I wish them both all the luck in the world in the paths that lie ahead of them.
            In John Steinbeck’s classic novel Of Mice and Men, the story’s protagonists, George and Lenny, dream of a day when they will no longer labor as migrant workers, living hand-to-mouth, from one week’s wages to another.  I believe that this American dream, of a time when we might all secure safety under our own vines and fig trees, is possible only through education.  My own grandfather, Bernard Davis of blessed memory, worked at a printshop by day, and took night classes in order to earn his degree.  He went on to become a high school math teacher, and was able to send all three of his own children to college, two of whom now teach.  This, in a sense, was his American dream, and without his hard work to educate himself, I would not be where I am right now: I do not owe my place here in Cornell to my own merit.  We should be cautious about being overly prideful in our own talents and accomplishments.  As we approach Pesach, the most educational of all holidays, in which we are instructed to recount our people’s history to our children, let us bear in our hearts the two-and-a-half-millennium old words of the prophet Yirmiyahu, which conclude this week’s Haftorah: “Let not the wise man boast of his wisdom, nor the strong man boast of his strength, nor the rich man boast of his riches.” (9:22).  Rather, we should be conscious of the roles our teachers and communities have played in our own formation as mature Americans.  May you have a Shabbat Shalom.

~JD

"La position des Italiens vis-à-vis de la Solution finale en Europe a rendu extrêmement difficile l’application des mesures recherchés" [The position of the Italians regarding the Final Solution in Europe rendered the application of the sought-after effects extremely difficult] (Heinrich Müller, as quoted in Serge Klarsfed, La Shoah en France, 234).

Sunday, March 4, 2012

Curricular Diversity I

Last Monday evening, I found myself discussing The Return of Martin Guerre, the history of a trial which took place in rural 16th-century France, to a friend of mine. As I began to explain the book’s premise, and why I was writing a paper about it, my friend, who happens to be in the College of Engineering, asked me with complete and utter candor whether a justice system already existed in Europe in the 1560s. Without showing my surprise, I responded that there was, adding that it took many of its precedents from Roman Law.[*] My friend is intelligent, hard-working, and bilingual, and the fact that he was not even aware that Renaissance France had a system of courts, judges, and parlements is merely the most recent example I have encountered of the low standards of historical education in our society. History is the most-disliked subject among High School students, and is particularly unpopular among racial minorities, and I do not know whether our culture dislikes history because of the way it is taught, or whether it is taught inadequately because we consider it not worth teaching well.

Although as a history major and potential historian or history teacher, I take historical ignorance somewhat more seriously than the rest of you might, historical ignorance among the well-educated is, I think, one particular manifestation of a more general problem in our education system. I am referring to ignorance of fields outside of our own specialty, whatever it may be. Education is meant to broaden one’s minds and one’s horizons, and make one aware of the larger world: education ought not to sharpen the mind by narrowing it.

Before I continue, I would first like to combat three antithetical myths. The first is that of a division between the natural sciences and the humanities. Most of us have heard this before, and most of you probably disagree with it at some level: according to this theory, one’s mind is either suited to math-and-sciences, or to the humanities. One will receive a 760 on the Math section of the SAT, and a 590 on the Critical Reading section because one is, in a sense, fated to do so. This theory is even supported by the quasi-scientific explanation of the division of the left and right sides of the brain (by which people really mean the telencephalon), one associated with quantitative reasoning, and the other with creative tasks. Somehow, the existence of these two halves means that one must be superior to the other, and that therefore, one side, and therefore one talent, predominates. Although I do not wish to dispute laterization of brain functions,[†] this fact should no more lead to the supposition that one is only capable of using one or the other side, any more than the fact that one of one’s shoes fits better than the other should lead one to conclude that one should wear only one shoe at a time. We all have special talents (or maybe not), this should not preclude our seeking to learn a relatively more difficult subject.

The second myth, again brought up by a friend of mine the other day, who was praising 19th-century (and earlier) methods of Jewish education, in which the same teachers taught all subjects to a group of students, from physics to Tanakh, and from astronomy to Talmud. He seemed to think that the existence of specialty teachers is due to the lack of recognition that all laws, whether Halachic or physical, derive from the same source. Disregarding the theological origin of this statement, what he didn’t seem to realize was that until the early years of the 20th century,[‡] a single learned person could reasonably hold most scientific knowledge in his head. This is even more so before works of such physicists as Copernicus, Galileo, Descartes, Leibniz, and Newton in the 16th and 17th centuries. Before this, those with sufficient intelligence and leisure time could fit all scientific knowledge inside of their heads, with room to spare: living in the 12th century, the Rambam learned his physics by reading Aristotle and the classical commentators. He found that Yechezkel’s divine vision squared remarkably well with the world of Aristotle. This myth is even more spurious than the first: in order to fully understand a field of science, one must work in a well-equipped laboratory: in order to fully understand a field of history, one must read all relevant secondary-source literature, and spend extensive time in archives. It is difficult to even be a specialist in history-in-general, specifically, because one cannot remain on top of the vast amount of research in every field, and follow the shifting historiographic river of claim, counter-claim, and compromise.

Because all fields, from astrophysics to the classics, are all changing so much so quickly all the time, we can no longer understand just what it is that Stephen Hawking studies, or just what makes M theory so trippy. This can sometimes lead to a feeling of intellectual helplessness, which brings me to the third myth: that nobody can ever really understand anything, and therefore shouldn’t try. In Travels with Charlie, a Yankee farmer complains to John Steinbeck that “My grandfather knew the number of whiskers in the Almighty’s beard. I don’t even know what happened yesterday, let alone tomorrow. He knew what it was that made a rock or a table. I don’t even understand the formula that says nobody knows. We’ve got nothing to go on — got no way to think about things.” In other words, because most of us can’t tell a charmed blue quark from a Higgs boson, or wrap our heads around the Mandelbrot set, or explain oxidative phosphorylation to a small child, we should never open up a book on science. This is patently false and quietist approach: as the logic goes, because we cannot know everything, we cannot know anything.

This is not a purely academic discussion. Ignorance of the basic facts of life has real-world consequences. Sallie Tisdale, describing her work as nurse in an abortion clinic, recounts a dialogue with a patient, which is simply one example of the damage caused by the ignorance of one’s own body:

“When’s the baby going to go up into my stomach?”

“What do you mean?”

“Well, when women get so big, isn’t the baby in your stomach? Doesn’t it hatch out of an egg there?”

This is an egregious example of misinformation, but regardless of your position in the abortion debate, I think that you can probably agree that this patient would not have found herself in such a quandary (medical or ethical, take your pick), had she known more about human reproduction.

Leaving you on that note, this blog post is turning out to be longer than I had expected. When I get to part II, I will go on to flesh out my argument, explaining why even academics should learn subject matter from other fields, and how, within the Cornell community, we can make it easier for them.

~JD

“Overnight, foreign lenders’ confidence collapsed and economic policy floundered in internal bickering. The International Monetary Fund imposed draconian conditions in return for new loans, while overseas creditors demanded that the regime guarantee the entire private foreign debt of the companies that had been taken over — about $7.7 billion — or risk jeopardizing their agreements for new loans. The desperate officials had no choice but to sign, thus fully protecting foreign banks while passing the burden on to domestic taxpayers. During the boom, Chile’s economic gains had been privatized; now, in the crunch, the country’s losses were socialized” (Constable and Valenzuela, A Nation of Enemies: Chile Under Pinochet, 197).



[*] In fact, many Americans might be surprised to know that the justice system in most of the American states more closely resembles the legal code of the French Ancien Regime, which shares common roots with the English Common Law introduced in the thirteen original American colonies, than it does contemporary French Law, based upon the Napoleonic Code formulated in the early 19th century. Not to say there are not major differences, such as the existence in modern American trials of a jury of peers, and the ban on torture. If you’re interested on experiencing firsthand the differences between the Common Law and the Napoleonic Code, commit a crime first in New York, and when you’re finished doing time, drive to Louisiana and commit the same crime there.

[†] The two hemispheres are, in fact, quite good at compensating the one for the other, provided that damage occurs earlier in one’s life rather than later. A 19th-century autopsy once revealed that a normal, functioning human being had apparently lived his whole life with only one hemisphere.

[‡] The real turning point occurred in the years 1923-1924, when physicists finally ditched the old Newtonian model of the universe, having realized that the fact that energy came in tiny packets known as “quanta” threw much of what they thought they knew about the universe to the winds.